August 2006 Newsletter from The Restored Homestead
Click for RestoredHomestead web page
 
August 2006

Plywood vs. Composite Wood Products?

 

Hello Dear Readers!

 

While we complete our plans for the Heald Cottage and the Pierce Homestead to be built on Yankee Way in Brookline, NH, our thoughts turn to wood, - and not because our chicken coop is full of 200 year old beams, either!  As builders, we must make choices about how our houses will be constructed and, in this day of engineered wood, the choices are many.

 

We also realize most people who purchase new construction really haven’t much knowledge about building materials.  So in this article we include links to various sites in case you want to explore further on your own.

 

The colonial builders of the old houses we love so dearly used wide rough-cut boards for wall sheathing and flooring underlay.  Plywood was the first type of engineered wood to be invented  (actually the clever Egyptians used layered veneers of wood way back when – but we’re talking about more recent history).

 

Plywood came into use in the early 1900’s.  It’s made from thin sheets of wood veneer stacked together alternating the grain of each sheet and glued under heat and pressure to create strength.  Creating plywood requires using large, older growth trees big enough to be placed on a lathe and peeled into veneer sheets. But building demand here and abroad has encouraged manufacturers to search for cost-effective ways to use more variety of trees – and younger ones. (visit http://www.apawood.org for an industry manufacturer’s perspective).

 

Enter engineered wood products that are made by grinding up wood and gluing wood strands, particles, and fibers into usable building materials.  Different glues have been developed for different product applications but the most used are urea-formaldehyde resins (inexpensive but not waterproof) and phenol and melamine-formaldehyde resins (water resistant).

 

Oriented Strand Board, OSB, is the most common alternative to plywood.  In many parts of the country it is fast replacing plywood as builders product of choice as it is less expensive.  But OSB has its detractors.  While many engineering studies refute contentions that OSB is more prone to nail-pops, few argue that OSB’s most serious drawback is its tendency to swell in high humidity or when it gets wet.  So manufacturers of roofing and flooring materials (such as tile) are more cautious in their recommendations for using OSB as a substitute for plywood.  Here’s a good link for you to read the pros and cons of plywood vs. oriented strand board:

http://www.umass.edu/bmatwt/publications/articles/osb_vs_plywood.html.

 

 

We’ve decided to use time-proven plywood in our construction.

 

 

And now a quick review of some of the types of engineered wood products you might encounter:

 

Plywood http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/plywood

Laminated Veneer Lumber:  LVL http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/laminated_veneer_lumber

Oriented Strand Board: OSB http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/oriented_strand_board

Particleboard (chipboard)  http://en.wikipedia.org/particleboard

Masonite  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/masonite

 

Maxcy Fisher FloorIn next month’s issue we’ll talk about why you should NEVER throw away old flooring – we don’t care how beat up it is – and how you can recycle it into beautiful floors.

 

Trompe L'oeil Art
Maxcy Fisher Deed

How did folks plan their retirement in colonial days?

When Maxcy Fisher’s parents decided to sell him the family homestead, they worked out a deal that would assure them a place to live.  Maxcy was not yet married, - but clearly planning that happy event – and so he and his parents agreed they would continue to own a third of the home, its outbuildings, livestock, gardens and, yes, manure pile.  This was a common arrangement for the times; we’ve encountered similar divvying up of property among children and parents in prior deeds.  Given that the extended family was an important part of family life in the 18th century, we created a trompe l’oiel painting of the deed between Maxcy and his parents as a reminder of the close family arrangements of earlier days.

 

Do You Know?

Where did the expression “Dead as a Door Nail” come from?

 

 

 

 

 

Think about it for a bit and email us with your answer. You will find the answer in our next issue.

The Builder's Corner

Master Carpenter

Pen Burnam

Pen BurnamI’ve been a carpenter for over 30 years, so I may be set in my ways, but I like real wood. I’m working right now on a house with 250 year old beams that are as strong as anything engineered. But we don’t have beams like these anymore.  But the engineered beams (LVLs) are incredibly strong and there’s nothing better today for carrying long loads.

As far as plywood goes,  I think it’s better than OSB.  When OSB gets wet, it gets real thick and I figure either the strands are going to disintegrate or the glue is going to give way.  OSB comes with a film on it that’s supposed to repel water, but if you have to cut it, then the seal’s broken.  And let’s face it, we work outside in all kinds of weather – stuff gets wet on the delivery trucks and it gets wet on site while we’re building.  Down the road, homes being what they are, roof flashing can leak, plumbing can leak, toilets can leak – all that stuff happens over the years.  And we really don’t know how OSB – and engineered wood, in general - will hold up.

I know lumber companies have been closing down plywood plants driving prices up on plywood.  So I guess engineered wood is in our future for good.  But, like I say, I’m an old carpenter and I’ll probably be long gone before that day arrives so, for now, I’ll stick to wood.

Preview

The Pierce Homestead

CLICK to read more about the Pierce Homestead

We will talk more about this lovely saltbox in our next issue.  The Ebenezer Pierce homestead is a rare find, for saltboxes are much sought after by homebuyers around the country. Many have been “exported” from their original communities and rebuilt in such unlikely places (we think!) as Arizona and California.  So it’s harder to find saltboxes than capes, for example – and particularly one this old.

This is a beauty – and shortly we will have a full set of elevations and visualizations of the finished “old new” house on our website to be rebuilt on Yankee Way in Brookline, NH.  If you would like further information, just call or email.

Click HERE to Forward Our Newsletter to Your Friends

©2006 Restored Homestead LLC, Restored Homestead® is a registered trademark of Restored Homestead LLC, All rights reserved.
No part of this newsletter may be duplicated in any form without the expressed written permission of Restored Homestead LLC